Table of Contents
Overview
- WP Mail SMTP
A trusted plugin that helps configure WordPress emails by integrating with third-party email providers. It’s a solid choice for enhancing email reliability but relies heavily on external tools. - Site Mailer
An innovative solution that replaces traditional SMTP configurations entirely. It simplifies email deliverability by eliminating third-party integrations, offering a true plug-and-play experience tailored for WordPress users.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
WP Mail SMTP |
Site Mailer |
|
|---|---|---|
| Email Logging |  |
|
| Built-in SPF, DKIM, DMARC | |
|
| Single Payment |  (external fees apply) |
|
| Unlimited Daily Emails | |
|
| Testing Options | |
|
| Send Emails Without Integration | |
|
| Domain Name Verification (DNS) | |
|
| Custom Domain Setup | |
|
| Quick & Easy Setup | |
|
| Price | $50 + provider fees | $48 (all-inclusive) |
Key Features in Detail
1. Email Logging
Both tools offer detailed email logs to support troubleshooting and analysis. Site Mailer provides access to logs up to the current day, while WP Mail SMTP allows access to logs up to the previous day.
Here are WP Mail SMTP’s logs:
And here is Site Mailer’s logs, which include logs arrived today:
2. No API or Integration Needed
WP Mail SMTP requires integration with a third-party email provider, such as SendGrid or Amazon SES, which adds complexity.
Site Mailer eliminates this step by directly connecting to your WordPress site, making setup fast and hassle-free.
3. Unlimited Daily Emails
Third-party providers used by WP Mail SMTP often impose daily email limits, restricting high-volume users.
Site Mailer offers unlimited daily emails at no additional cost—ideal for users with large mailing lists.
4. Built-in List-Unsubscribe Headers
Site Mailer makes it simple to comply with email best practices by including built-in List-Unsubscribe Headers.
With just a toggle, recipients can unsubscribe effortlessly. This feature is absent in WP Mail SMTP unless manually configured.
5. Suppression Management
Site Mailer keeps your email lists clean by automatically managing unsubscribes and invalid addresses, improving deliverability.
WP Mail SMTP does not offer this feature.
6. Failure Reason Troubleshooting
When emails fail, Site Mailer provides immediate, actionable feedback to help you resolve issues quickly.
WP Mail SMTP only offers failure logs for the previous day, delaying resolution.
7. Domain Name Verification and Custom Domain Setup
Setting up domain authentication with WP Mail SMTP requires external configuration. In contrast, Site Mailer includes a guided wizard to verify your domain, configure DNS records, and set up custom domains effortlessly.
8. Price
- WP Mail SMTP: Starts at $50/year, not including additional fees for third-party providers.
- Site Mailer: $48/year all-inclusive, with no hidden fees or surprises.
Why Choose Site Mailer?
While both tools excel in essential features like email logging and SPF/DKIM/DMARC support, Site Mailer goes above and beyond with:
- No daily email limits.
- Plug-and-play setup with no external integrations required.
- Built-in List-Unsubscribe Headers and suppression management.
- Instant troubleshooting and domain setup guidance.
- A simpler, more affordable pricing model.
Conclusion
If you’re looking for a comprehensive, hassle-free email deliverability solution, Site Mailer is the clear winner. It’s designed for users who value simplicity, advanced features, and an all-inclusive pricing model.
Looking for fresh content?
By entering your email, you agree to receive Elementor emails, including marketing emails,
and agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
